Comparison
ThirdProof vs. Spreadsheets
for Vendor Risk Management
91% of organizations still manage vendor risk in spreadsheets. Here's why autonomous investigation replaces manual tracking — with better coverage, in a fraction of the time.
Try ThirdProof Free →No credit card required
Spreadsheets
ThirdProof
Time per vendor assessment
4-6 hours (manual research + data entry)
Under 2 minutes (fully automated)
Data sources checked
2-3 (Google search + vendor website)
24 intelligence sources in parallel
Sanctions screening
Manual OFAC lookup (if remembered)
Automated OFAC, EU, UN + entity verification
Cyber risk scoring
Not typically included
Automated security posture analysis
Adverse media coverage
Manual Google News search
Multi-API news scan with relevance filtering
Certification verification
Trust the vendor's claim
3-tier: independently verified / vendor attested / not found
Risk scoring method
Subjective (analyst opinion)
Deterministic rules engine (same data = same score)
Audit readiness
Auditor questions every data point
SHA-256 sealed PDF with source citations
Scalability
Linear — each vendor = same hours
Investigate 25+ vendors/month on Starter plan
Cost per assessment
$200-600 (analyst labor at $50-100/hr)
$15.96/investigation (Starter plan)
Common questions about replacing spreadsheet TPRM
Can I replace my TPRM spreadsheet with ThirdProof?+
Yes. ThirdProof replaces the manual research and data entry portion of spreadsheet-based TPRM. Instead of spending hours Googling each vendor, copying data into cells, and hoping you checked everything, ThirdProof autonomously queries 24 intelligence sources and produces a structured risk report. You still make the approve/reject decision — ThirdProof gives you the evidence to make it confidently.
What does ThirdProof check that spreadsheets miss?+
Most spreadsheet-based assessments check 2-3 things: the vendor's website and maybe a Google search. ThirdProof checks sanctions databases (OFAC, EU, UN), business registries (GLEIF), adverse media (multiple news APIs), domain security (TLS, DNS, security headers), network exposure (Shodan), threat intelligence (VirusTotal, AbuseIPDB), certification claims (trust page scanner + FedRAMP registry), subprocessor supply chain risk, SEC EDGAR filings, and FDIC bank failure records. Each source that would take 20-30 minutes manually runs in parallel in seconds.
How much does spreadsheet-based vendor risk management cost?+
The hidden cost of spreadsheet TPRM is analyst time. At $50-100/hour, a thorough manual assessment takes 4-6 hours per vendor — that's $200-600 per assessment. For 50 vendors per year, that's $10,000-30,000 in analyst labor alone, not counting the cost of missed risks. ThirdProof's Starter plan covers 25 investigations/month for $399 ($15.96 per investigation), with more depth than manual research provides.
Is ThirdProof better than a GRC platform for vendor risk?+
ThirdProof and GRC platforms serve different needs. GRC platforms (OneTrust, ServiceNow GRC) manage the workflow: tracking which vendors need review, routing approvals, storing documentation. ThirdProof provides the investigation: the actual risk data, findings, and evidence that feeds into your GRC workflow. Many teams use ThirdProof to generate the risk assessment, then upload the PDF report to their GRC platform as evidence.
Replace your TPRM spreadsheet today
Your first investigation is free. See how ThirdProof compares to your current process.
Start Free Investigation →No credit card required